This is my blog…nacho blog


Tragedy strikes every day and everyone has a different definition for what a tragedy is. To me tragedy can mean a lot of things, but in this case I am talking about a woman losing her life. The day after Christmas. Because of a drunk driver. Who after 4 DUI convictions STILL HAD A VALID LICENSE! How did this happen? That’s the question on a lot of people’s lips today.

You can read the full story on The Burlington Free Press website. The basic gist? 52 year old Timothy Dowd was pulled over for running not one but TWO stop signs. As the officer approached his vehicle, he sped off. He was in downtown Burlington, a popular area for traffic – both vehicular & pedestrian. At speeds sometimes exceeding 50 MPH (and several more stop signs and stop lights ignored) he tried to elude police but failed miserably when he slammed into Kathryn “Kaye” Borneman’s car and killed her instantly. His blood alcohol level 4 hours after the crash was .071. The legal limit is 0.08. They are working on determining his level of intoxication at the time of the crash (he refused any alcohol analysis at the scene – apparently an innocent woman’s death & his prior 4 convictions still gave him this option?) but my assumption is he was shitfaced.

Regardless, I want to know how a man who has been convicted FOUR TIMES of Driving Under the Influence can legally obtain a license. Yes, only 1 of those was in Vermont (2 were in New York and the other in Pennsylvania) but don’t those records haunt you wherever you go? They should! His reasons for not pulling over were silly: he was driving the car of an acquaintance; he was unfamiliar with the area; the car’s brakes & mirrors were bad; he was in pajamas (yes, he cited that as reason for not pulling over!). And yes, he is sorry (he told police he no longer wished to live) but he also stated that “I don’t get behind the wheel of a car and drive drunk, I don’t do it, it’s not my style…circumstances happened tonight, that, you know, I found myself in bad circumstances.” Excuse me?! I think the four DUI convictions you have speak differently!

This story infuriates me for so many reasons. There’s the obvious things that I have discussed such as how does a man like Dowd legally possess a driver’s license (while I don’t because my inspection/registration were expired – hence my bus riding for the last three months) but there are other things. Like the friend I lost to a drunk driver in 1999. He was walking home from a party (where everyone was too drunk to drive him – he was sober and without a car) and he was hit so hard by a car that when he was thrown down an embankment, his shoes stayed behind. It was all terribly horrific as any young, unexpected death is. It’s something that has stayed with me and I’m sure most of my classmates in the 10+ years since it happened.

Another reason I am outraged is because so many people are trying to place blame on the Burlington Police Department – as if they had a hand in Kaye’s death. Excuse me?! What are you smoking (and will you share?)? Yes, this is the second time a police chase has ended in a crash in 6 months. But saying the police are to blame is in effect saying that we don’t need them to do their job. They can sit around the station eating donuts and watching grainy surveillance footage – just don’t pull people over for suspicious behavior because then you might chase them and then THEY might crash into someone and kill them. Hell no! Timothy Dowd was scared of getting in trouble again (maybe he should have thought about that BEFORE he got behind the wheel of car while he was DRUNK!) so he ran. He was concerned only with saving himself. The officers chasing him? Put their lives on the line Sunday night too. How about that?

So yes, this all could have been avoided. If Timothy Dowd would have put down the Shiraz or not picked up the car keys. There is nothing BPD could have done differently (based on the facts we have) to help make sure an innocent life was not senselessly lost. If nothing else, please let this serve as a reminder. Do NOT get behind the wheel of a car if you have had too much to drink. I know it’s easier said than done. I also know that I have made my share of silly mistakes over the years. But, this New Year’s Eve, remember that it’s not just you on the road. If you drink, you put everyone else on the road at risk too. Please be safe this holiday season and all through the year. XO

5 responses

  1. I cannot believe that the police are being blamed. They are doing their job. This scum CHOSE to drink and get behind the wheel. It comes down to just that.

    I’m positive he wasn’t forced to drink or that he was embarassed to stop in his pajama’s or that he didn’t notice the stop signs he ran.

    I was fortunate to survive a head on collision with a drunk 20 years ago. I was stopped at a red light when he came into my lane and hit my car so hard that his car climbed the hood of mine and almost came through the windshield. I had 8 witnesses and the tow truck driver was the one that found the open Yukon Jack and the open prescription pills on the drivers front seat.

    He was not arrested on sight. He was not arrested at the hospital. According to the attorney that I had for that case, this asshole had a history as well and hit someone the very next day!!!

    Sure, his insurance company (yes I was lucky he was insured) paid me 3 times the value of my car, but my own insurance company dropped me because I was involved in a DUI. Now that’s irony.

    Funny how a person can be arrested and imprisoned a minumum of 5 years and charged with a felony possession for a mere ounce of marijuana, but get behind the wheel after drinking and injure or kill another human being and the prison term and fines are minimal.

    I only hope that Ms. Borneman’s family will receive the justice that is deserved and that this piss poor excuse of a human being is finally taken off the street for good.

    December 28, 2010 at 7:41 pm

    • Chris – this story sickens me. I’m glad you’re ok but I’m sorry you had to endure this. So terrible…

      December 29, 2010 at 11:29 am

  2. Back in April we lost a friend to a drunk driver as well. He was a decorated war hero who earned, among other awards, a bronze star for his service in Iraq. He was also a first responder at the Pentagon on 9/11.

    He was back in Orlando with his daughters and working as a correctional officer at a local jail. On his way home from work he was struck and killed by a drunk driver with 3 prior drunk driving convictions. His killer has since been released from jail yet again until his trial. No doubt he’s back on the road. He didn’t have a valid license when he hit and killed our friend, so even taking their license away won’t stop some people.

    I truly hope that when this case finally goes to trial they lock him up and throw away the key. I guarantee you his time in jail will be less pleasant than normal since he killed a CO. He deserves all the “special” treatment he’ll receive.

    December 29, 2010 at 11:49 am

  3. tmana

    As your experience confirms, drivers licenses do not make safe drivers. Conversely, lack of a license does not stop people from driving — safely or not. Many NYC news stories of car collisions entail a driver whose license was not simply suspended for a period of time, but permanently revoked (and across all of the United States).

    Rather than be derailed by the question of licensure, the drivers should be made legally liable for the costs of the harm they have caused through careless, reckless, or inexperienced driving.

    Sadly, requirement of reparations is largely ignored by law enforcement and the judicial branch — consider, for example, the recent Colorado case in which a wealthy financial analyst was all but allowed to go free after carelessly running down a cyclist, fleeing the scene, and hiding his damaged car behind a closed drinking establishment.

    The bottom line is that of the Golden Rule: He Who Has the Gold, Makes the Rules. Unless and until that changes — and it won’t; it’s human nature — there can not be effective sanctions for drunk or distracted driving.

    December 29, 2010 at 2:59 pm

  4. Thank you Saucy. I do feel very fortunate. Sure I sustained injuries that I will have for the rest of my life, but so many others have lost so much becuase of DUI’s.

    My condolences to you Stacey for your loss. Your friend was not only that to you and many others, but a hero of this nation.

    Hopefully one day lawmakers can all be on the same page when it comes to DUI convictions.

    December 29, 2010 at 6:55 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s